Recipe Substitution for Canned Condensed Cream Soups

Recipe Substitution for Canned Condensed Cream Soups: healthier alternatives for any recipe! Plus super easy to make.

Recently I’ve been on a quest to learn how to cook from scratch. I have been blundering through this assignment in an orderly manner for the past several months. You’d never think there could be such well-planned disasters. But to my dismay, planned menus don’t always lead to a good meal. Things like whole wheat pasta and homemade tortillas and even peanut butter cookies are vicious creatures waiting to attack if you are caught off guard.

Since I am a pragmatist, I used to rely heavily on recipes that called for condensed cream soups—you know, cream of mushroom, cream of chicken and cream of celery. I gave these up for the assignment because of some suspicious ingredients: MSG, tons of sodium, preservatives with long names. Not to mention, I discovered that canned foods in general are suspicious because can lining is made of BPA (toxic chemical). Oh yes. AND—have you ever noticed that the soup sort of maintains the shape of the can when you pour it out? That just seemed wrong and gross.

But I started missing the taste (and convenience) of those condensed soup based recipes. I did some research and found the perfect, pragmatic solution: homemade condensed cream soup substitutes. What’s great about them is that you can prepare them in less than ten minutes!

Here’s what you need. This is the substitute for one can of condensed cream of chicken:

2 T butter
3 T flour
1/2 c chicken broth
1/2 c milk
Salt and pepper

Melt the butter in a saucepan over medium heat. Stir in the flour. Slowly stir in the milk and chicken broth and heat the mixture until it bubbles. Keep stirring the whole time. When it bubbles, reduce heat and continue stirring until it thickens.  When it’s thick, add salt and pepper to taste (a few shakes is good).

Voila. More natural cream of chicken soup, ready to go into your recipe.

I am thrilled about this discovery—not only is it a pragmatic substitute for condensed cream soups, but it is tastier, healthier and easy to alter. Here are a few more tips:

  • For low-fat versions, use 1 T butter and nonfat milk.
  • For a condensed cream of celery soup substitute, saute about 1/4 c of finely chopped celery in the butter until tender before you add flour. Don’t use chicken broth (unless you want to have chicken flavor) – use a full cup of milk instead.
  • For a condensed cream of mushroom soup substitute, saute about 1/4 c of finely chopped mushrooms in the butter for 2-3 minutes before you add the flour. Use a full cup of milk instead of half milk, half broth.
  • To adjust consistency, increase or decrease the amount of flour you use.
 cream soup substitute
Update March 2016: Four years later, I’m a better cook and this is one of my staples for all those creamy dishes I crave. Enjoy!
Gina signature

Hey, I'm Gina!

I’m a wife and mom of five, with kids ages toddler to teenager. I’m created in the image of God, made whole in Jesus. In this online space, I help others overcome the overwhelm all of us face when navigating this messy, beautiful journey we call life. Want to join us?

Read About...

Latest Posts

Freebies

Gina M Poirier is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for websites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

9 Comments

  1. Anonymous

    A little wordy before getting to the point for my taste, but then that's the pragmatist in me. I appreciate the time and effort it took to come up with these substitutes and will certainly remember them. Good to know. Thank you.

    Reply
  2. Gina @ Holding the Distaff

    I appreciate the pragmatic feedback! I'll add a line at the top telling people to skip to the bottom if they don't want to listen to my rambling.

    Reply
  3. Cowgirl in the City

    Gina, this is the best post! Thank you! My husband is allergic to MSG, and so many of my go to "comfort food" recipes use canned condensed cream soups as a base. This will help me out so much!

    Thanks again, Amy in Denver
    aka "the Cowgirl in the City"

    Reply
  4. in the coop

    Your world will really open up now that you have this recipe. It is also the base for the best mac and cheese and icing for red velvet cake (minus the chicken stock, of course) Oh, and Au gratin potatoes, and on and on and on. Good for you, getting healthy and cooking from scratch!

    Reply
  5. Steph

    Mmmmm. I love food made from scratch! Thanks for the recipe, I will try it next time I am making a casserole of some kind!

    Reply
  6. Gina @ Holding the Distaff

    Thanks for your responses! I'm really glad I "discovered" this trick. Maybe I'll become a food blogger (haha, or not. Worst food blog ever). But I'll post any other good finds I have in the future.

    Reply
  7. Allie Spann

    So good to know! I will be doing this! Thanks!

    Reply
  8. Nancy

    Thank you I’m allergic to msg. Now I can make some of my recipes that has been sitting around. My daughter is also happy she missed some of the dishes. Thank you again.

    Reply

What do you think? Leave a reply.

%d bloggers like this: